Japanese children’s book review: “だんながなんだ” (danna ga nan da)

By | June 6, 2018

Raising a child bilingually (or bi-culturally) can enrich him or her with the knowledge about a culture different from where they are living now. However, putting aside the advantages of learning a second language, it can be said that some of this cultural knowledge can still be gained via translations.

However, in rare cases you will come across books that are difficult, if not impossible, to translate and maintain the meaning of the original text.

The book I would like to review this time is a perfect: “だんながなんだ” (danna ga nan da) by 宮西達也 (Tatsuya Miyanishi), published by Holp Shuppan Publications, Ltd. If I were to make an attempt to translate the title I could say “What’s with the husband?” but that would completely omit an important element of the title. (Note: the full title of the book is actually サカサかぞくの だんながなんだ)

Why? Well, the reason the title is not really translatable is the same reason that makes this book so unique: both the title and every sentence within is a palindrome (called 回文 or 逆さ言葉 in Japanese). That is, reading every sentence backwards sounds the same as reading it normally. I remember when I was young I thought English palindromes like ‘radar’ and ‘racecar’ were pretty cool, but to have sentence-length palindromes is the next level of palindrome-greatness!

It must have really taken some skill for the author to craft these sentences, although to be sure the structure of the Japanese language helps create them (Wikipedia contains a list of other Japanese works utilizing palindromes), especially the fact that words have less letters on average than English, and that vowels and consonants are generally stuck together in a single letter. While some of them do seem a little forced (muriyari), overall they are pretty amazing, especially considering this is a 40 page book. I would like to have given a few more examples, but I returned the book to the library before I had a chance to write this review. I do remember one more, though: “すたみなみたす” (sutamina mitasu)

As for the book’s art, I’m extremely picky about visuals and I’ll have to admit I don’t personally enjoy the author’s style that much. However, I must admit he has created a unique style for himself. And the story? Well, it didn’t really stand out to me, but again I don’t think that is the best thing about this book. But neither of these points would stop me from renting this book again to read to my son.

By the way, this author is probably more well known for his Tyrannosaurus Series, which includes the book “You Look Yummy” that has been translated to English. On amazon it says this series has 12 titles, and has over 3 million in sales across several countries.

All in all, this “だんながなんだ” a pretty unique book, and I highly recommend checking it out, for both those who are raising their children bilingually, or just studying Japanese themselves. I checked a few E-book retailers and couldn’t find it sold there, so it seems like the only place it is available at present is in paper form on Amazon Japan here.

 

(Visited 66 times, 1 visits today)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.